Il’yash Karaimovich, Timosh Khmel’nitskiy and M. Kizilov

Александр Бабаджан

babadzan.krym@yandex.ua
(Ukraine)

Abstract

This paper contains a discussion together with the conclusions and assumptions presented in M. Kizilov’s article entitled Ильяш Караимович и Тимофей Хмельницкий; кровная месть, которой не было. The present paper endeavours to prove that M. Kizilov forged the sources he used in order to defame the person of Seraya Shapshal and other Karaite leaders.


Keywords:

Il’yash Karaimovich, Timosh Khmel’nitsky,, Seraya Shapshal, Karaites, Mikhail Kizilov

References

Голобуцкий В.А. Запорожское казачество. Киев, 1957, стр.462 Google Scholar

Okolski Sz., Dyaryusz transactiey wojennej migdzy wojskiem koronnem i zaporoskiem w r. 1637. Краков, 1858. Google Scholar

Величко С. Летопись событий в Юго-Западной России в XVII веке. Т. 1. К., 1848 Google Scholar

Gawronski Rawita Fr. Bohdan Chmielnicki do Elekcyi Jana Kazimierza, Львов, 1906. Google Scholar

Mardkowicz Al. O Iljaszu Karaimowiczu zwerzchniku wojsk zaporoskich», Луцк, 1931 Google Scholar

Костомаров Н.И. Богдан Хмельницкий. М. 1994. Google Scholar

Gini C.-I. Caraimi di Polonia e Lituania// Genus. –Roma,1936 – N2 – P.1-56. Google Scholar

Reicher M. Sur les groupes sanguins des Caraimes de Troki et de Wilno// Anthropologie. – Prague, 1932. –N9. – P.259-267. Google Scholar

Steiniger F. Bieder von Karaimen und Tataren in Ostlande// Natur und Volk, 1944, 10, s. 39-40. Google Scholar

Ustawa o stosunku Państwa do Karaimskiego Związku Religijnego w Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej// Dziennik Ustaw Rzeczypospolitej Polskiej – 1936. – N30 – s.548-552. Google Scholar

Сборник старинных грамот и узаконений касательно прав и состояния русско-подданных караимов, с предисловием В.Смирнова, СПб, 1890. Google Scholar

Kowalski T. Karaimische Texte im Dialekt von Troki. Prace Komisji Orientalistycznej Polskiej Akademii Umiejętności № 11, Kraków, 1929 Google Scholar

Лебедев В.В. К источниковедческой оценке некоторых рукописей собрания А.С.Фирковича. Палестинский сборник. Выпуск 29(92). История и филология. Ленинград. Наука, 1987, с. 57-63. Google Scholar

J. Stepaniv. L'epoque de Danylo Romanovyc (milie du XIIIe siecle) d'apres une source Karaite. HARVARD. Ukrainian Studies, vol.II, nr.3, 1978 Google Scholar

Кизилов М., Ильяш Караимович и Тимофей Хмельницкий; кровная месть, которой не было, Karadeniz Arastirmalari, Cilt: 6, Say1: 22, Yaz 2009, s. 43-74. Google Scholar


Published
2016-12-30

Cited by

Бабаджан, А. (2016). Il’yash Karaimovich, Timosh Khmel’nitskiy and M. Kizilov. Karaim Almanac, 5, 177–186. https://doi.org/10.33229/ak.2016.05.10

Authors

Александр Бабаджан 
babadzan.krym@yandex.ua
Ukraine

Aleksander Babadżan, absolwent matematyki na Symferopolskim Uniwersytecie, pracuje jako programista. Od 1990 r. bada karaimską historię, kulturę i religię, wyniki swoich badań prezentuje na konferencjach. Autor szeregu publikacji z dziedziny karaimoznawstwa. W roku 2001 uzyskał tytuł religijny erbi, a w 2013 wybrany został na hazzana Symferopola.



Statistics

Abstract views: 115
PDF downloads: 111


License

Authors 

Authors of texts accepted for publication in Karaim Almanac are required to complete, sign and return to the Editorial team’s office the Agreement for granting a royalty-free license to works with a commitment to grant a CC sub-license.

Under the agreement, the authors of the texts published in Karaim Almanac grant Polish Karaim Association a non-exclusive, royalty-free license and authorize the use of Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-ND 4.0) Creative Commons sub-license.

The authors retain the right to the free disposal of the work.

Users

Interested Internet users are entitled to use works that have been published in Karaim Almanac since 2018, under the following conditions: 

▪     attribution – obligation to provide, together with the distributed work, information about the authorship, title, source (link to the original work) and the license itself. 

▪     no derivatives – the work must be preserved in its original form. Without the author's consent, it is not possible to distribute the modified work in the form of translations, publications, etc. 

Copyrights are reserved for all texts published before 2018.

Miscellaneous

Polish Karaim Association retains the property right as a whole (layout, graphic form, title, cover design, logo etc.).

Privacy statement

The names and email addresses published on this journal site will be used exclusively for the purposes declared by this journal and cannot be used for any other purpose or by any other party.