1. Home
  2. Archives
  3. Vol. 11 (2022)
  4. Polemics and controversies

Remarks on the attitude toward S.M. Shapshal in Persia

Александр Бабаджан

babadzan.alex@gmail.com
Ассоциация крымских караимов «Крымкарайлар»Религиозная объединённая община «Чолпан» (Lithuania)


Abstract

The article examines the charges brought against S. M. Shapshal for his activities during his stay in Persia. It is shown that their main are Russian slanderous articles, consisting of unsubstantiated accusations with lack of awareness of the authors and unreliable evidence of the period of the information struggle of England and her henchmen in Persia and Russia against the Shah and the influence of Russia in Persia. The distribution of false information is shown by the example of the publication of M. Kizilov “The Sons of Script” and D. Shapira. The facts of the real attitude of the government of Persia after the overthrow of Shah Ali Mohammed to S. M. Shapshala are given, confirmed by documents stored in the S. M. Shapshala F143 fund in the Library of the Academy of Sciences of Lithuania.


Keywords:

S.M. Shapshal, Karaites, Persia 1905-1911, Iran 1905-1911, Mohammed Ali Ahah, M. Kizilov, D. Shapira, K. N. Smirnov

References

Bibliografia Google Scholar

Arabadžân, Z. (2018). Razgon Medžlisa Mohammedom Ali-Šahom v 1908 g. i anglo-russkoe soperničestvo v Irane. Vestnik Instituta vostokovedeniâ RAN. (4), 94–102. Google Scholar

Browne, E. G. (1910). The Persian revolution of 1905-1909. Cambridge. Google Scholar

Ivanov, M. (1957). Iranskaâ revolûciâ 1905-1911 godov. Moskva. Google Scholar

K…r (22 kwietnia 1904). Pisʹma iz Tegerana: Ot našego korrespondenta. Ûžnyj Kraj. Harʹkov. Google Scholar

Kazem-zade, F. (2004). Borʹba za vliânie v Persii: Diplomat.: Diplomatičeskoe protivostoânie Rossii i Anglii. Moskva. Google Scholar

Kizilov, M. (2015). The sons of scripture: The Karaites in Poland and Lithuania in the twentieth century. Warszaw [u.a.]: De Gruyter Open. Google Scholar

Mamedova, Z. Na puti k revolûcii: Poâvlenie iranskih političeskih partij v Baku (nač. XX v.). Po knige avtora «Problema ûžnyh azerbajdžancev v sovetskom Azerbajdžane v 20h-30h gg. XX veka». Baku 2018. Pobrane z: https://azerhistory.com/?p=33693. Google Scholar

Protest protiv kandidatury S. M. Šapšala: [na rolʹ gahama]. (1911). Karaimskaâ žiznʹ. (7 (dekabr)), 17–118. Google Scholar

Shapira, D. (2005). A Jewish pan-turkist: Seraya Szapszał and his work Qırım Qaray Türkleri (1928). Acta Orientalia Academiae Scientiarum Hungaricae, 58(4), 349–380. Google Scholar

Ter-Oganov, N. Neizvestnyj arhivnyj material o Sergee Markoviče Šapšale (Adib-Soltan). Pobrane z: http://shorashim.narod.ru/case_ter_oganov.htm. Google Scholar

Download


Published
2022-12-30

Cited by

Бабаджан, А. (2022). Remarks on the attitude toward S.M. Shapshal in Persia. Karaim Almanac, 11, 201–221. https://doi.org/10.33229/ak.2022.11.3

Authors

Александр Бабаджан 
babadzan.alex@gmail.com
Ассоциация крымских караимов «Крымкарайлар»Религиозная объединённая община «Чолпан» Lithuania

Aleksander Babadżan, absolwent matematyki na Symferopolskim Uniwersytecie, pracuje jako programista. Od 1990 r. bada karaimską historię, kulturę i religię, wyniki swoich badań prezentuje na konferencjach. Autor szeregu publikacji z dziedziny karaimoznawstwa. W roku 2001 uzyskał tytuł religijny erbi, a w 2013 wybrany został na hazzana Symferopola.



Statistics

Abstract views: 45
PDF downloads: 46


License

Authors 

Authors of texts accepted for publication in Karaim Almanac are required to complete, sign and return to the Editorial team’s office the Agreement for granting a royalty-free license to works with a commitment to grant a CC sub-license.

Under the agreement, the authors of the texts published in Karaim Almanac grant Polish Karaim Association a non-exclusive, royalty-free license and authorize the use of Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-ND 4.0) Creative Commons sub-license.

The authors retain the right to the free disposal of the work.

Users

Interested Internet users are entitled to use works that have been published in Karaim Almanac since 2018, under the following conditions: 

▪     attribution – obligation to provide, together with the distributed work, information about the authorship, title, source (link to the original work) and the license itself. 

▪     no derivatives – the work must be preserved in its original form. Without the author's consent, it is not possible to distribute the modified work in the form of translations, publications, etc. 

Copyrights are reserved for all texts published before 2018.

Miscellaneous

Polish Karaim Association retains the property right as a whole (layout, graphic form, title, cover design, logo etc.).

Privacy statement

The names and email addresses published on this journal site will be used exclusively for the purposes declared by this journal and cannot be used for any other purpose or by any other party.








Deklaracja dostępności